Whether a rental property beats an index fund depends on what the rental actually earns after the loan, so put both choices on the same sheet with the same cash. In a hypothetical $250,000 rental collecting $2,200 a month, a loan at an assumed 7.5% leaves the property about $160 a month short before major repairs, and at those assumptions the rental loses. If the seller carries the same loan at 5%, the rental keeps about $143 a month, and the choice comes down to your cash, your time, and the risks you're willing to carry.

Prefer to watch? Watch the full video on YouTube.

Rental house or index fund?

You've saved enough for a rental down payment, and you're trying to decide whether that money does more in a rental house or in an index fund now that mortgages cost around 7%. As of Freddie Mac's November 19, 2026 survey, the 30-year fixed average was 7.28%. That survey tracks loans on homes the borrower lives in, and a loan on a rental can price higher, so the example below assumes 7.5%.

Getting the comparison wrong can mean a rental that takes money out of your pocket every month. The way to avoid that is to run the rental with realistic costs first, then hold it up against the index fund and the CD with the same starting cash.

Run the rental with realistic costs

Take a hypothetical $250,000 rental house collecting $2,200 a month. Allow 5% for vacancy, then set operating expenses at 45% of the income after vacancy. Rounded, the year looks like this:

  • Gross rent: $2,200 a month is $26,400 a year.
  • Vacancy at 5%: $1,320, which leaves $25,080.
  • Operating expenses at 45% of $25,080: $11,286.
  • Net operating income: about $13,794 a year, or about $1,150 a month.

Net operating income, or NOI, is what's left after vacancy and operating expenses but before you pay the mortgage or major repairs. At a $250,000 price, $13,794 of NOI is about a 5.5% cap rate.

The loan leaves a monthly shortfall

With 25% down, your cash in the deal is $62,500 and you'd borrow $187,500. At an assumed 7.5% over 30 years, principal and interest come to about $1,311 a month.

The NOI is about $1,150 a month, so the property comes up roughly $160 a month short, or close to $1,940 a year, before major repairs. Under these assumptions, your $62,500 down payment hasn't bought any monthly income.

A lender would see the same problem. The debt-service coverage ratio, or DSCR, is NOI divided by the yearly loan payments, and in this example it's about 0.88. A ratio below 1 means the rent doesn't cover the loan, and many lenders want that ratio comfortably above 1, so this loan may not get approved as written. A 5.5% cap rate against a 7.5% loan is also what investors call negative leverage, which why a big apartment REIT walked away from two deals explains on a much larger building.

Three ways to change the rental numbers

Maybe the price could come down, maybe the seller would carry the note at a lower interest rate than the bank, or maybe you should pass.

  1. A lower price. At the same rent, expenses, 25% down, and 7.5% loan, the price would have to drop to about $219,000, roughly 12% below $250,000, just to break even each month before major repairs and reserves.
  2. Seller financing. If the seller financed the same $187,500 at 5% over 30 years, the payment would be about $1,007 a month, and the same NOI would leave about $143 a month instead of coming up $160 short. That's about $1,716 a year on your $62,500, or about a 2.7% cash-on-cash return before closing costs and major repairs, and the DSCR rises to about 1.14.
  3. Pass. If the price and the terms won't move, the rental doesn't work at these numbers, and you go make another offer.

Raising the rent in a spreadsheet doesn't help unless local renters can and will pay the new amount. The $200 per door test and how I bought a rental without a bank loan show how I check the rent and the terms before I offer.

What the index fund and the CD promise

The rental can feel discouraging after that math, and it might make the index fund look like the easy answer. The next question is what the alternatives actually promise you.

A certificate of deposit, or CD, is a bank deposit that pays a stated rate for a set term, subject to its terms and deposit insurance limits. An index fund buys a small share of many companies at once, but its value can fall, and historical stock returns aren't a check you can count on next year.

Compare the same cash over the same time

I compare the same starting cash, the same time horizon, and the cash I might need along the way. Each choice carries its own costs and risks:

  • The rental has transaction costs, repairs, vacancy, management work, and less liquidity, meaning it's harder to turn into cash quickly.
  • The index fund has market risk, so the balance can be lower right when you need the money.
  • The CD may charge an early withdrawal penalty and may not keep pace with inflation after taxes.

The better choice is the one that wins on the same sheet with your own numbers. At these assumptions, the rental loses until the price or the terms change.

Which choice works on your numbers

I kept my corporate job while I built my first rentals, and keeping a job while you learn gives you room to make this comparison without demanding that the first rental replace your paycheck. Run the property with realistic costs, compare it with current alternatives, and make another offer if the first house doesn't fit.

Some sellers won't offer terms, but if you never ask, you'll never find the ones who will.

The recap

  • A hypothetical $250,000 rental at $2,200 a month, with 5% vacancy and expenses at 45% of income after vacancy, has NOI of about $13,794 a year, or about $1,150 a month.
  • With 25% down, a $187,500 loan at an assumed 7.5% over 30 years costs about $1,311 a month, so the rental runs about $160 a month short before major repairs. DSCR is about 0.88.
  • The rental breaks even at a price of about $219,000 with the same rent and loan terms.
  • Seller financing at 5% drops the payment to about $1,007 and leaves about $143 a month, or about 2.7% a year on the $62,500 down payment before closing costs and major repairs.
  • An index fund's value can fall, a CD has terms, penalties, and insurance limits, and a rental has transaction costs, repairs, vacancy, work, and less liquidity. Compare all three with the same cash and the same time horizon.
  • As of Freddie Mac's November 19, 2026 survey, the 30-year fixed average was 7.28%.

The house, the rent, the 5% vacancy, the 45% expense ratio, the 25% down payment, and the 7.5% and 5% loans are hypothetical teaching examples, not a real listing or a financing quote. A seller may not accept those terms. NOI, payments, monthly balances, and returns are rounded. Historical stock returns aren't guaranteed, and CDs have terms and insurance limits. This guide is for education only and isn't financial, tax, or legal advice.

Learn to run both sheets before you buy

If you want to learn how to underwrite a property before you put your money into the deal, come join us in Commercial Real Estate 101 on Skool. Inside, we teach you how to run both sheets the same way and structure rental offers, including seller financing, so you know whether the rental beats the alternatives before you commit your cash.

Run the rental with real costs, price the loan, and make an offer the house can carry.

Frequently asked questions

Is a rental property better than an index fund at 7% mortgage rates?

It depends on what the rental earns after the loan, so compare both with the same cash and time horizon. In a hypothetical $250,000 rental at $2,200 a month, a loan at an assumed 7.5% leaves the property about $160 a month short before major repairs, so the rental loses at those assumptions. With a 5% seller-financed loan, the same rental keeps about $143 a month.

How do you calculate cash flow on a rental property?

Start with the yearly rent, subtract vacancy and operating expenses to get net operating income, or NOI, then subtract the loan payments. In the example, $26,400 of rent minus 5% vacancy and expenses at 45% of the remaining income leaves NOI of about $13,794 a year, or about $1,150 a month, against a loan payment of about $1,311 a month.

What can fix a rental that has negative cash flow?

A lower price, better terms from the seller, or passing on the deal. In the example, the price would need to drop to about $219,000 to break even before major repairs, or a seller-financed loan at 5% would cut the payment to about $1,007 a month. Raising the rent only helps if local renters can and will pay it.

What risks should you compare between a rental, an index fund, and a CD?

A rental has transaction costs, repairs, vacancy, management work, and less liquidity. An index fund's value can fall, and historical returns aren't guaranteed. A CD may charge an early withdrawal penalty, has deposit insurance limits, and may not keep pace with inflation after taxes.

Where are mortgage rates right now?

As of Freddie Mac's November 19, 2026 survey, the 30-year fixed average was 7.28%. That survey tracks loans on homes the borrower lives in, and a loan on a rental can price higher, which is why the example assumes 7.5%.