An 11% cap rate can be a good deal, but only if the property still covers the loan with room to spare after you add the expenses the seller left out. In a hypothetical $720,000 listing with $79,200 of advertised net operating income, a $540,000 loan at 7.5% leaves a debt-service coverage ratio of about 1.75. If the real NOI is 15% lower, coverage falls to about 1.49. You don't get to spend the cap rate, so price the loan and check the expenses before you offer.
Prefer to watch? Watch the full video on YouTube.
What an 11% cap rate means
Cap rate is the building's yearly net operating income divided by the price. Net operating income, or NOI, is the income after vacancy and operating expenses but before the mortgage. You can read more on the cap rate and NOI basics pages.
Use a hypothetical property priced at $720,000 with an advertised NOI of $79,200. Divide $79,200 by $720,000 and you get the advertised 11% cap rate. That number can make the listing look like a bargain, and it tells you nothing yet about your loan.
Price the loan before you trust the cap rate
Suppose you put 25% down, which is $180,000, and borrow $540,000 at an assumed 7.5% over 30 years. The loan payments come to about $3,776 a month, or about $45,300 a year. The 7.5% rate is an assumption for this example. Your commercial loan quote will depend on the property, the lender, and your terms.
What debt-service coverage tells you
Lenders compare the NOI with the yearly loan payments using the debt-service coverage ratio, or DSCR. DSCR is NOI divided by the annual loan payments.
In the example, $79,200 divided by $45,300 is about 1.75. The advertised income covers the loan payments 1.75 times. A ratio above 1 only means the income is bigger than the payment, and it doesn't prove the purchase is safe. How a bank tests a 40-unit deal walks through the same coverage check on a bigger building.
Check the seller's expense sheet
The comfortable 1.75 depends on whether the seller's expense sheet included every cost you'll pay. Imagine the seller left out costs, and the real NOI is 15% lower at $67,320. The same loan is then covered about 1.49 times.
The deal still pays the assumed loan, but the margin is smaller. Here's how the example changes, rounded:
- Advertised: NOI of $79,200, an 11% cap rate, DSCR of about 1.75, and about $33,900 a year left after the loan payments.
- After the 15% cut: NOI of $67,320, about a 9.35% cap rate at the same $720,000 price, DSCR of about 1.49, and about $22,000 a year left after the loan payments.
That leftover cash is before reserves, and major repairs like a roof still need their own budget. The advertised 6 cap that wasn't and why a deal can look great on paper show how often the seller's NOI runs high.
What the cap rate doesn't verify
An 11% cap can still be a good deal. The advertised percentage doesn't verify collections, expenses, building condition, or your loan terms. A weekly home-mortgage rate survey isn't your commercial financing quote either.
Before I'd offer on a high cap-rate property, here's what I'd check:
- Ask for the rent roll and the actual collections, meaning the rent that was actually paid.
- Compare the seller's expenses with real bills.
- Find out when the roof and major systems will need work.
- Get a lender quote for the property itself.
- Test whether income can fall while I still cover the debt and keep reserves.
When I'd ask the seller to carry part of the price
If the bank's terms make the coverage too thin, I ask whether the seller would carry part of the price. A seller note at a lower rate can lower the yearly loan payments and give the deal more room. How to run owner financing numbers on a commercial deal shows how to model that note, and the seller financing page covers the basics.
Decide on the offer
The 11% cap is only cheap if the deal still works after the loan and the real expenses. If the seller's price requires every unit to pay on time and nothing expensive to break, you need a lower price, better terms from the seller, or a different deal. Put the property's income and your actual borrowing terms on the same sheet before you decide whether the return is worth your cash.
Some sellers won't move on price or terms, but if you never make the offer, you'll never find out.
The recap
- Cap rate is NOI divided by price. In the example, $79,200 divided by $720,000 is an 11% cap rate.
- A $540,000 loan at an assumed 7.5% over 30 years costs about $45,300 a year, so DSCR on the advertised NOI is about 1.75.
- If the real NOI is 15% lower at $67,320, DSCR drops to about 1.49, and the cap rate at the same price is about 9.35%.
- A high cap rate doesn't verify collections, expenses, building condition, or your loan terms. Check the rent roll, the bills, the major systems, and a real lender quote.
- If the coverage is too thin, ask for a lower price or seller financing on part of the price, or pass.
The property, the $79,200 advertised NOI, the $540,000 loan, the assumed 7.5% rate over 30 years, and the 15% NOI reduction are hypothetical teaching examples, not a real listing or a financing quote. Loan payments, coverage ratios, and cash figures are rounded. Verify the income, expenses, condition, and loan terms on the property in front of you.
Learn to price the loan before you commit your cash
If you want to learn how to underwrite a property before you put your money into the deal, come join us in Commercial Real Estate 101 on Skool. Inside, we teach you how to price the loan, check the seller's numbers, and structure offers, including seller financing, before you commit your cash.
Pull the rent roll, get a real quote, and make an offer the building can carry.
Frequently asked questions
Is an 11% cap rate a good deal?
It can be, but only if the property still covers the loan with room to spare after the real expenses. In a hypothetical $720,000 listing with $79,200 of advertised NOI, a $540,000 loan at an assumed 7.5% has a debt-service coverage ratio of about 1.75. If the real NOI is 15% lower, coverage falls to about 1.49.
How do you calculate a cap rate?
Divide the building's yearly net operating income by the price. Net operating income, or NOI, is the income after vacancy and operating expenses but before the mortgage. $79,200 of NOI on a $720,000 price is an 11% cap rate.
What is the debt-service coverage ratio?
DSCR is NOI divided by the annual loan payments. A DSCR of 1.75 means the income covers the loan payments 1.75 times. A ratio above 1 only means the income is bigger than the payment, and it doesn't prove the purchase is safe.
What happens to the deal if the seller left out expenses?
In the example, a 15% lower NOI of $67,320 drops DSCR from about 1.75 to about 1.49, and the cap rate at the same $720,000 price falls to about 9.35%. The deal still pays the assumed loan, but the margin is smaller, and major repairs like a roof still need their own budget.
What should you check before offering on a high cap-rate property?
Ask for the rent roll and actual collections, compare the seller's expenses with real bills, find out when the roof and major systems will need work, get a lender quote for the property, and test whether income can fall while you still cover the debt and keep reserves. If coverage is too thin, ask about seller financing on part of the price.
Join the community 