A 24-unit listing can show 92% occupancy and an 8% cap rate, with numbers that check out, and still fail if operating income drops 20% in a bad year. Take a hypothetical building listed at $2,625,000 with $210,000 of annual net operating income. When I'm advising investors on how to evaluate a real estate deal, I run a coverage test on the loan before I treat the advertised cap rate as a reason to buy.

Prefer to watch? Watch the full video on YouTube.

Start with the advertised numbers, then price the loan

Occupancy tells you how many units are filled. You still have to check whether the income can support your debt. In this hypothetical example, the building is about 92% occupied, listed at $2,625,000, with $210,000 of annual net operating income, which is the income after vacancy and operating expenses and before the mortgage. Divide $210,000 by the price and you get the advertised 8% cap rate. No real property or seller is being described.

Now assume you borrow 75% of the price at 7.5% over 25 years. The $1,968,750 loan would take about $174,600 a year in payments. The debt service coverage ratio, which is net operating income divided by the annual loan payments, comes out to about 1.20. The income covers the payments with some room, but not a large cushion.

This assumed loan is for teaching, not a financing offer. I also wrote about pricing the loan on an advertised cap rate, and about why an advertised 6 cap can be the wrong number.

What happens in a bad year

Suppose operating income falls 20% because collections weaken, concessions rise, meaning you give tenants free rent or discounts to sign, or expenses go up. Net operating income becomes $168,000, and coverage falls to about 0.96. The income no longer covers the loan payments, even before major repairs.

The 20% drop example doesn't prove the seller lied. An offering memorandum, which is the broker's marketing package for the building, can show accurate current numbers that still become inadequate when conditions change. Your job is to check the records and see how much room the purchase leaves.

A break-even check, still on this same hypothetical loan, tells you how far income can fall before coverage hits 1.0, meaning the income just equals the annual payments. Coverage hits 1.0 at about $174,600 of net operating income, which is about a 17% drop from $210,000. A 20% drop takes coverage below 1.0, to about 0.96.

If you want the same 1.20 coverage after a 20% income drop, the purchase price on this assumed loan would need to be about $2,105,000, or about $520,000 below the $2,625,000 list price. The $2,105,000 price is a teaching example on the same loan terms, not an offer.

The bank's DSCR test walks through how lenders look at that coverage number, and deals that look great on paper covers what happens when the operating income doesn't hold up.

What I'd verify before I bid

I would compare the leases with actual collections and the last 12 months of operating bills. Then I'd budget major repairs separately and ask the lender for terms on that specific building, because the assumed loan here is for teaching, not a financing offer.

If the bank's terms leave the coverage too thin, I ask whether the seller would carry part of the price at a lower rate, because a smaller yearly loan payment gives the building more room in a bad year. On the same hypothetical $1,968,750 loan over 25 years, a 5% seller note would take about $138,100 a year in payments. Coverage would be about 1.52 on $210,000 of net operating income, and about 1.22 on $168,000 after a 20% drop. That 5% rate is a teaching example, not a financing commitment, and no seller has to accept it. How to run owner financing numbers on a commercial deal walks through that payment math, and the balloon test for seller financing covers what happens if a large payment comes due early.

A listing that looks fine on the advertised numbers can still fail if a realistic setback pushes coverage below 1.0. Stress the income and expenses before you decide on the bid. If a bad year leaves you unable to pay the loan, you may need a lower price, more equity, seller financing at a lower rate, or a different property. Finding the problem before closing gives you choices you may not have after you own the building.

Some sellers will say no, but if you never make the offer, you'll never find the building that passes the test.

The recap

  • Occupancy tells you how many units are filled. You still have to check whether the income can support the debt.
  • In this hypothetical 24-unit example, a $2,625,000 price and $210,000 of net operating income produce an 8% cap rate. A 75% loan at 7.5% over 25 years takes about $174,600 a year in payments, and coverage starts at about 1.20.
  • After a 20% drop in operating income, net operating income is $168,000 and coverage falls to about 0.96, below what's needed to pay the loan, even before major repairs.
  • Coverage hits 1.0 after about a 17% income drop. To keep coverage at 1.20 after a 20% drop, the price on this assumed loan would need to be about $2,105,000.
  • On the same loan amount at 5% seller financing over 25 years, annual payments would be about $138,100, and coverage after a 20% income drop would be about 1.22.
  • Compare the leases with actual collections and the last 12 months of bills, budget major repairs separately, and ask the lender for terms on that specific building.

The 24-unit property, 92% occupancy, $2,625,000 price, $210,000 net operating income, assumed loan at 75% of price with 7.5% interest over 25 years, 20% income drop, break-even price, and 5% seller-note figures are hypothetical teaching examples, not a real property, seller, or financing offer. Payments and coverage ratios are rounded. Major repairs need a separate budget. This guide is for education only and is not financial, tax, or legal advice. Check the numbers and the terms on the property in front of you with the proper professionals.

Learn to underwrite a building before you put money in

If you want to learn how to underwrite a property before putting your money into the deal, come join us in Commercial Real Estate 101 on Skool. Inside, we teach you how to stress test a building and structure offers, including seller financing, that can survive a bad year.

Stress the income and expenses before you bid, and only move forward on a purchase that still covers the loan in a bad year.

Frequently asked questions

Does a deal with an 8% cap rate survive a 20% income drop?

A deal with an 8% cap rate can fail a 20% income-drop test even when the listing numbers are accurate. In a hypothetical 24-unit example listed at $2,625,000 with $210,000 of net operating income, a 75% loan at 7.5% over 25 years starts at about 1.20 coverage. After a 20% drop in operating income, coverage falls to about 0.96, below what's needed to pay the loan, even before major repairs.

What is debt service coverage ratio, or DSCR?

Debt service coverage ratio is net operating income divided by the annual loan payments. Net operating income is the income after vacancy and operating expenses and before the mortgage. In the hypothetical 24-unit example, coverage starts at about 1.20 and falls to about 0.96 after a 20% income drop.

How far can income fall before coverage hits 1.0?

On the same hypothetical $1,968,750 loan, coverage hits 1.0 at about $174,600 of net operating income, which is about a 17% drop from $210,000. A 20% drop takes coverage below 1.0, to about 0.96.

What purchase price would keep 1.20 coverage after a 20% income drop?

On the same assumed 75% loan at 7.5% over 25 years, the purchase price would need to be about $2,105,000, or about $520,000 below the $2,625,000 list price. The $2,105,000 price is a teaching example on the same loan terms, not an offer.

How can seller financing change coverage in a bad year?

A smaller yearly loan payment gives the building more room in a bad year. On the same hypothetical $1,968,750 loan over 25 years, a 5% seller note would take about $138,100 a year in payments. Coverage would be about 1.52 on $210,000 of net operating income, and about 1.22 on $168,000 after a 20% drop. That 5% rate is a teaching example, not a financing commitment.